Do you want a cookie?

Green thumbs, watch out! We use cookies on our website - not the delicious ones for snacking, but the digital helpers. They enable us to find out how our website is used. If you click on "Accept", our virtual garden gnomes will be happy and promise to guard your data like their own watering can. You can find more information in our Privacy Policy.

Blog Artikel Banner Bild

Cultivation or Direct Sowing: When and Which Vegetables to Propagate?

26.02.2022  /  Reading time: 12 minutes

In spring, we amateur gardeners have our hands full: Bed preparations, maintenance work and the first sowings are on the agenda. To make the most of the gardening year, it is crucial that the young plants are ready at the right time. When it comes to growing young plants, you are spoilt for choice: do you want to sow directly into the bed or would you prefer to pre-grow your plants indoors? To make your decision easier, you can find out everything you need to know about the two sowing methods and which plants are suitable for each here.

This article contains:

  1. Propagating Vegetable Plants: Advantages of Pre-Cultivation
  2. Which Vegetables Need to Be Preplanted?
  3. When to Sow Seeds for Vegetables Seedlings?
  4. Pre-cultivation of Vegetables: What You Need to Know
  5. Direct Sowing and Its Advantages
  6. Suitable Plants for Direct Sowing
  7. What You Should Consider When Direct Sowing
  8. FAQ

Quick Overview

Growing Your Own Vegetable Seedlings Pays Off

  • Earlier sowing possible
  • Protection of young plants from snails & competition from wild herbs
  • More economical use of seeds
  • Growing conditions are easier to influence

Advantages of Direct Seeding

  • Plants become more robust
  • The roots are not damaged by transplanting
  • The connection between the young plant and the soil remains intact

Which Vegetables Should I Sow Directly?

  • Especially plants with sensitive roots, including root vegetables such as carrots, beetroot and radishes.
  • Beans and peas
  • In principle, almost any vegetable can be sown directly in beds

Propagating Vegetable Plants: Advantages of Pre-Cultivation

When pre-cultivating indoors, you can influence the growing conditions to give the seedlings a good start. For example, you can use Special Potting Compost that is relatively lean. This promotes root formation in the young plants, as they have to develop more space in their search for nutrients. There is also a relatively constant temperature in the house, which is particularly important for plants with a high germination temperature. Pre-growing vegetable plants can have even more advantages and can be useful depending on the crop and region. You can find all the advantages of propagation below.


Earlier Sowing and Harvesting

If you pre-grow your plants in a warm house on the windowsill, you can start sowing before the last frosts. In a warm spot, your tender young plants will be protected from the cold and won't suffer any damage. Early sowing also allows you to harvest earlier. This extends the growing season, which makes it possible to harvest particularly heat-loving crops such as peppers and tomatoes. You can find out how to preplant tomatoes and what you need to bear in mind here.

Protection Against Pests and Weeds

The protective four walls not only protect your seedlings from the cold, but also from pests and wild herbs. In an unprotected vegetable patch, young plants are often a tasty morsel for snails and could also quickly be overgrown by wild herbs. As soon as your plants are larger, they will be better able to hold their own against other plants and establish themselves in the vegetable patch.

Save Seeds

You can use your seeds much more sparingly when pre-growing. They cannot be blown away, washed away or snatched by birds. In addition, you don't sow generously in rows, but rather selectively in seed trays or pots. Alternatively, You Can Also Make Soil Pots With a Soil Baler for Plastic-Free Cultivation.


Pre-growing pumpkin plants on the windowsill
Pumpkin plants enjoy warm cultivation indoors.

Which Vegetables Need to Be Preplanted?

It is particularly worthwhile to propagate slow-growing and heat-loving plants indoors. They require a relatively high germination temperature and can make good use of the extended growth phase. These include nightshade plants (tomatoes, aubergines, peppers, etc.) and pumpkin plants (courgettes, cucumbers, melons, etc.). You Can Find More Tips and Instructions for Growing Peppers and Chillies in This Article.

Various types of cabbage (head cabbage, Brussels sprouts, kohlrabi, etc.) also benefit from early sowing indoors, as they grow relatively slowly. As soon as it is warm enough outside, they can be planted out in the bed to make the most of the summer! As the tender leaves of young lettuce are often eaten by snails, lettuce is also often grown in advance. Unlike the nightshade and pumpkin plants, however, it is not absolutely necessary to pre-grow the plants. There can also be advantages to sowing these plants directly.


Banner Hintergrund

Get More Information in Our Library

In our library you will find information on the individual varieties with cultivation periods, tips on sowing, planting and harvesting. You will also find good and bad companion plants to help you plan a mixed crop.

View Library Now

When to Sow Seeds for Vegetables Seedlings?

Most seed packets indicate the optimum time for sowing indoors and outdoors. For most plants, you can start growing indoors in early to mid-March so that the plants can be planted outdoors after the Ice Saints in mid-May. If you don't have time to grow your own vegetable plants this year, you can of course always buy young plants from the market, gardener or garden centre.


Pre-cultivation of Vegetables: What You Need to Know

Make Sure There Is Enough Light

When pre-cultivated in a protected room, the plants may become very weak due to a lack of stimuli. If they do not get enough light, for example, they will grow unnecessarily tall and will not be able to bear their leaves later on with their unstable shoots. So make sure they get enough light! If you only have a few bright spots available, you can also use special UV lamps to help. You Can Find out More About Plant Lamps for Growing Plants in This Article.

Watch the Temperature

When choosing a location, you should also make sure that it is not too warm. In this case, the motto ‘a lot helps a lot’ does not apply. The plants should not be placed on a radiator, as the soil would dry out too quickly. A bright spot on the windowsill at a moderate room temperature is completely sufficient for growing!

Ensure Sufficient Moisture

This brings us directly to the next and very important point: sufficient moisture. Especially in the germination and early development phase, you should always ensure sufficient moisture. If the soil dries out repeatedly, the seeds cannot germinate properly. In addition, a lack of water can very quickly cost a tender young plant its life.


You can find Everything You Need to Know about Growing Vegetable Plants in this article. We give you numerous tips on how to successfully grow healthy seedlings.


Vegetable patch with salads and herbs
As soon as the last frosts are over, plants that need warmth, such as basil, can be planted in the bed.

Direct Sowing and Its Advantages

Direct sowing also has its advantages. You can find out what these are and which vegetable plants are better sown directly below.

More Robust Plants

Direct-sown plants are generally more robust; they are hardened by a wide range of environmental influences. The wind, for example, ensures that the plants grow more stably due to the constant stimulus. The robust young plants are also less susceptible to pests (e.g. aphids) in comparison, they just must not fall victim to snails.

No Pricking or Transplanting

What also speaks in favour of direct sowing is the stress factor that arises when transplanting. Transplanting always means stress for plants! In nature, a change of location is actually only intended for the seed. It is carried away by animals or the wind to germinate in another place. Once the seed has sprouted and taken root, it has no reason to move, as the growing conditions appear to be suitable. The change of location is therefore only due to human intervention and not only damages the roots, but also tears the young plant out of its familiar environment.

Consistent Growth

A diverse flora of bacteria, fungi and other microorganisms lives in the soil. This flora can support the germination of seeds. When the seed sprouts, it automatically connects to the complex network in the soil. If the plant is then moved to another location, these connections are severed. The plant must then re-establish such connections in its new location in order to grow well. You have probably observed this before when planting young plants. At first the plants seem out of place, but after a few days you notice how they seem to connect with their surroundings and become stronger. Some plants manage to form new connections, but others are too weakened and die.


Our tip: Direct sowing saves you time anyway. With a Seed Tape, you can make your direct sowing even easier and more effortless. You can find out how to make your own seed tape in this article.


Harvested beetroot
Beetroot has relatively sensitive roots and should therefore always be sown directly. / Image by Tracy Lundgren on Pixabay

Suitable Plants for Direct Sowing

There are plants that should definitely be sown directly, as they have very sensitive roots. Transplanting would damage the roots and weaken the plant to an extreme degree. These include root vegetables such as carrots, beetroot and radishes. But beans and peas also thrive better when sown directly into the bed. You can find Tips on Sowing and Propagating Peas Here in this article. This is because they form a symbiosis with nitrogen-fixing bacteria in the soil. Legumes can only form this bond later when they are grown in advance. Pre-sowing is generally possible with lettuce and has advantages if you have to deal with a lot of snails in your beds. However, direct-sown lettuce is less prone to bolting. In general, most crops are suitable for direct sowing in the bed. Only slow-growing plants and those with a high germination temperature are worth growing indoors.

What You Should Consider When Direct Sowing

With these tips, you'll be well on your way to a rich harvest!


Ensure Sufficient Humidity

Even with direct sowing, sufficient moisture is essential during the germination phase! So make sure that your fresh seeds never dry out.

Protect Seeds With a Garden Fleece

If you want to sow directly into the bed despite cooler temperatures, you can use special garden fleece. The fleece has an insulating function and can thus create a favourable microclimate for germination. After sowing, you should regularly check whether germination has started and remove the fleece in good time so that the young plants can develop properly.

Press Seeds Well

To minimise seed loss, you should press the seeds down firmly. This is particularly important for light sprouts (e.g. lettuce), as the seeds are not covered with soil, but laid open on the ground. Additional bird netting can be helpful here to ensure that your seeds survive until germination and are not nibbled.


Bean seeds
Beans grow best when sown directly into the bed.

Whether pre-grown or direct sown, each of the two methods has its advantages and disadvantages. Ultimately, it depends on the plant chosen as to whether it is worth growing indoors or not.


If you have any questions or comments, please write to us at [email protected]. Would you like to receive helpful gardening tips all year round and plan your own beds optimally? Then register here or download the Fryd app for Android or iOS.

Fryd - your digital bed planner


author image
Author

Annabell

Annabell is studying agricultural biology at the University of Hohenheim. She also enjoys gardening in her private life, spends a lot of time in nature and loves to be creative.

Learn more

Current topics in the community

Avatar
mitdenhummelnbummeln 3 hours ago
I like
Respond

Liked 8 times

I had the honor to be part of this year's #seedexchangepackage2024. Many thanks to @Vive_Laterre for the effort and love that went into this campaign.🫶🏻 At this point I would like to get something off my chest: It is nice to be part of this community and to be able to meet people at eye level again and again, even if they are strangers, who also like to ground themselves in the earth and share the same attitude and love of nature. I find it very enriching here and am very grateful for it. I'm already looking forward to spring! 🐝 #seedexchangepackage2024 #dieliebezurnaturteilen #ichbinsodankbardafür #seed #eigenessaatgut

Show 2 answers
Avatar
Berta Wühlmaus 3 hours ago
I like
Respond

Hello to the community. I'm thinking about a raised bed for my patio and already have a candidate in mind. My question to you: In addition to the various fillings, soil is needed at the end. Can I use my potting soil from last year or does it have to be new? As I can't use all the old pots, I would have to dispose of the soil. It was only bought last year. I feel a bit overwhelmed by this question at the moment. I'm looking forward to your answers as I'm leaning towards being able to use the old soil.

Show 8 answers
Avatar
green feet bibi 7 hours ago
I like
Respond

Liked 8 times

The result in a mix with yacon. A very interesting tasting jam, apple would also have gone well with it. I added a little cinnamon, clove and vanilla. I think kiwano as ice cream or sorbet is also a great idea. The kiwano ripened very well over the 3 weeks. They were wonderful to spoon out. The taste was cucumber, banana and lime. The whole bowl had the consistency of frogspawn🤣. Pushing it through a sieve was a bad idea, it was too thick. The Flotte Lotte then did the trick. I had a yield of approx. 800g from 7 fruits. Now I just have to get the seeds free from the remaining goo.

Show 5 answers

Register for Free

You can quickly and easily register for free in our mobile app and use many more features.

These include:

  • Access to our community
  • Free mixed culture bed planning
  • Database with over 3,000 varieties of vegetables

FAQ

Pre-planting enables earlier sowing and thus harvesting, protection against pests and weeds, more economical use of seeds and better control over the growing conditions.

Nightshade plants such as tomatoes, peppers, aubergines and pumpkins are particularly suitable for propagation due to their need for warmth.

Plants that are sown directly develop more robustly, their roots are not damaged and the connection to the soil is maintained.

Plants with sensitive roots such as carrots, beetroot and radishes as well as beans and peas are particularly suitable for direct sowing.

Have You Heard of the Fryd App?

From growing to harvesting - plan your vegetable garden with Fryd

Joy Increases When Shared!

Become part of our Fryd community of garden enthusiasts! Ask your questions, get quick help, and share your knowledge to help others. Let’s grow!

Register for Free

You can quickly and easily register for free in our mobile app and use many more features.

These include:

  • Access to our community
  • Free mixed culture bed planning
  • Database with over 3,000 varieties of vegetables

Effortless Companion Planting, Zero Headaches!

Plan your companion plantings now for healthier, more resilient plants and harvest more than ever!